Trading Up on South Hill: Selling and Buying in One Move

By Clif Matthews, Licensed WA Real Estate Agent Published Updated 12 min read
South Hill Selling Tips

Trading up on South Hill, Puyallup means running two deals at once: selling the home you own and buying the next one, usually with the equity from the first paying into the second. The hard part is not the paperwork. It is the order. Sell first and you may need somewhere to live for a few weeks. Buy first and you are asking a seller to wait on your sale. Try to close both on the same week and every date has to hold.

This is the playbook I walk South Hill owners through. It covers the three ways to sequence the move, what the current market says about which one fits, and what the two forms that do most of the work actually say: the Northwest MLS sale contingency addendum (Form 22B, revision 2/26) and the seller rent-back agreement (Form 65B). I read both forms in full on November 18, 2026, along with the state law that governs rent-backs, and pulled the latest Realtor.com ZIP data for the South Hill ZIP codes. How you pay for the next home is a question for your lender. Everything below is about the contract and the calendar.

Trading Up on South Hill at a Glance

  • Three sequences: sell first (with a rent-back), buy with a sale contingency, or line up both closings together
  • Contingency clock: Form 22B gives you 45 days to sell unless you write in another date
  • Listing deadline: your home must be on the MLS within 5 days of mutual acceptance unless you write in another number
  • Rent-back limit: no more than three months after closing under Form 65B and RCW 59.18.040(3)
  • The market right now: 405 active listings and 123 pending across ZIPs 98373, 98374 and 98375 in October 2026, with median days on market of 43 to 64

Trading Up on South Hill, Step 1: Pick Your Sequence

There are three ways to do this, and each one moves the risk to a different place.

If you want a broader look at the sell-first or buy-first decision for a smaller next home, my Puyallup downsizing guide covers that side. This page is for the owner moving up.

Trading Up on South Hill, Step 2: Read the Market You Are Selling Into

The sequence that makes sense depends on how fast South Hill homes are selling right now. South Hill is unincorporated Pierce County, so there is no city-level market report for it. The closest public figures are the ZIP code files Realtor.com publishes each month. ZIPs 98373, 98374 and 98375 cover South Hill, though they also run past its edges in places, so read these as a close proxy, not an exact boundary. Here is October 2026, the latest month in the file, next to October 2025:

ZIP Active listings Oct 2026 Pending Oct 2026 Median days on market Oct 2026 Median days on market Oct 2025 Share with a price cut Oct 2026
98373 96 26 64 57 31%
98374 192 68 64 58 28%
98375 117 29 43 54 34%

Added together, the three ZIPs had 405 active listings and 123 pending sales in October 2026, about 3 pending for every 10 active. A year earlier it was 331 active and 154 pending, closer to 5 for every 10. Back in February 2026 there were 210 active and 161 pending. More homes are sitting, and they are sitting longer.

That cuts both ways for someone trading up. Your own sale is likely to take longer than it would have in the spring, which matters a lot for the contingency clock in Step 3. On the other side, a seller with fewer offers to compare is more likely to give a contingent offer a hearing. That is my read of the numbers, not a rule, and a well-priced home in a popular plat can still draw several offers in any month. For more on South Hill pricing trends, see my South Hill market analysis.

Step 3: Know What Form 22B Says Before You Write a Contingent Offer

In Washington, a sale contingency is written on NWMLS Form 22B, the Buyer's Sale of Property Contingency Addendum. The current revision is dated 2/26 (February 2026), the latest I could find on November 18, 2026. Here is what it says, paragraph by paragraph, in plain terms.

Run the numbers against the table above. The default 45-day period is shorter than October's median days on market in 98373 and 98374 (64 days in both). If you are listing this winter, you and your agent should talk about a longer contingency period before you write the offer, and about a list price that will actually draw a buyer. A contingency period you cannot meet is a contract that ends on its own.

Thinking About Trading Up on South Hill?

Tell me which home you own and what you want next. I will lay out how long South Hill homes like yours are taking to sell and which sequence fits your timeline.

Plan My Move With Me

Step 4: Plan for the Bump

A contingent offer does not take the seller's home off the market. Under paragraph 4 of Form 22B, the seller can keep the home listed in "Contingent" status until you have satisfied or waived your contingency. If another buyer comes along and the seller accepts their offer, that second offer has to include the Second Buyer's Addendum (Form 39), and the seller sends you a Bump Notice (Form 44).

From that notice you have the number of days written into your addendum, or 5 days if blank, or until your contingency period ends, whichever comes first. In that window you either show that your home is under contract or waive the contingency. If you do neither, your agreement ends and your earnest money comes back. If you waive, the form is blunt: waiving the sale contingency also waives every other condition in the agreement, including financing, and you close 30 days after you waive.

That last part is why I talk through the bump before a client writes a contingent offer, not after. Ask yourself now: if a second buyer shows up on day 20 and you have five days to decide, could you go forward without your sale and without any other contingency? If the answer is no, your realistic outcome in a bump is walking away with your earnest money, and you should know that going in.

Step 5: Set the Terms on Your Own Sale

Once you are under a Form 22B contingency, the seller of the home you are buying has some say over the offer you accept on yours. Paragraph 2 requires the seller's written consent (on Form 90L) before you accept an offer on your home that:

If you accept one of those offers without consent, the seller can end the deal within three days of your notice, and you would be in default. So when offers come in on your South Hill home, a clean offer with a 30 to 45 day close is worth more to you than its price alone suggests.

Two more rules to know. Once your home is under contract, your purchase is set to close 3 days after your sale closes, and you cannot change your sale's closing date without the seller's written consent. And if your sale falls apart, you have to tell the seller within 2 days. If that happens before your contingency period runs out, the contingency comes back to life for the rest of the period. If it happens after, the purchase ends and your earnest money comes back, unless you choose to waive the contingency and close 30 days later. For the rest of the seller side, from county records to closing, my South Hill seller checklist walks through it step by step.

Step 6: If You Sell First, Put the Rent-Back in Writing

Selling first is the lower-risk path on the contract side, and a rent-back is what makes it livable. A rent-back means you close the sale of your home and stay on as a renter for a short time while you buy the next one.

The standard purchase agreement (Form 21) gives the buyer possession at 9:00 p.m. on the Possession Date and says that if possession transfers at a time other than closing, the parties sign NWMLS Form 65B, Rental Agreement/Seller Occupancy After Closing, or another rental agreement. The newest copy of Form 65B I could read is revision 7/23. It says:

The three-month limit comes from state law. RCW 59.18.040(3) says a seller's post-closing rental is outside Washington's Residential Landlord-Tenant Act only if the agreement is in writing, lasts no more than three months, the home was not a distressed home at closing, and the seller was represented by a Washington attorney or licensed broker. Form 65B also carries a printed notice warning the buyer to talk to an attorney before agreeing, because a seller who will not leave can be hard to remove. That warning is why buyers in a multiple-offer situation sometimes say no to rent-backs, and why a short, clearly dated rent-back is easier to get than an open-ended one.

The pricing and timing side of selling first is in my guide to selling a South Hill home: timing and pricing.

Step 7: Build Your Trading Up Timeline on Paper

Before you write an offer on the next home, put both deals on one calendar. Here is the skeleton I use for a contingent purchase under Form 22B with the blanks left at their defaults. Your numbers will change if you write in different dates.

When What happens Form 22B source
Day 0 Mutual acceptance on the home you are buying Starts every clock below
Within 5 days Your South Hill home is listed on the MLS with a licensed firm Paragraph 1(a)
Any time Seller may accept a second offer and send a Bump Notice; you have 5 days to satisfy or waive Paragraph 4
2 days after your home goes under contract Notice to the seller with a full copy of your sale agreement Paragraph 5
Day 45 Contingency period ends: sold, waived, or the agreement ends and earnest money is refunded Paragraph 1(b)
30 to 45 days after your sale's mutual acceptance Your sale closes (a closing date outside that range needs the seller's consent) Paragraph 2(b)
3 days after your sale closes Your purchase closes Paragraph 5

Laid out this way, the squeeze is easy to see. If your home takes the October median of 64 days to go under contract, it misses a 45-day contingency period by almost three weeks. That is the conversation to have before you sign, not on day 40.

A note on what this page is and is not. I am a real estate agent, not an attorney. The forms described here are filled in by the brokers on each side, and anything written into the blanks or the "Other" paragraph changes how they work. If your situation is unusual, an attorney can review the agreement before you sign.

Trading Up on South Hill, Puyallup: Questions Sellers Ask

Can I buy a new home on South Hill before I sell mine?

Yes, with a sale contingency on NWMLS Form 22B. Your purchase goes forward only if your current home sells within the contingency period, 45 days after mutual acceptance unless you write in another date. The seller can keep marketing their home and bump you if a second offer comes in.

How long do I have to list my home under a sale contingency?

Five days after mutual acceptance if the blank is left empty, and periods of five days or less skip weekends and legal holidays. The home has to be on a multiple listing service with a licensed firm. If you miss the deadline, every condition in the purchase, including inspection and financing, is treated as waived and you close in 30 days.

What happens if the seller gets another offer while I am contingent?

The seller sends a Bump Notice (Form 44). You then have five days, unless a different number is written in, or until your contingency period ends, whichever is earlier, to show your home is under contract or waive the contingency. Waiving it waives all other conditions too, and you close 30 days later. If you do neither, the deal ends and your earnest money is refunded.

Does "sold" mean my home has to close before the contingency ends?

No. Form 22B defines sold as having a valid and enforceable purchase and sale agreement on your home. You give the seller notice within two days, with a copy of that agreement, and your purchase then closes three days after your sale closes.

How long can I stay in my home after I sell it?

Up to three months under NWMLS Form 65B. Washington law, RCW 59.18.040(3), keeps a written seller rent-back outside the landlord-tenant act only if it lasts three months or less, the home was not a distressed home, and the seller had an attorney or licensed broker. You pay the utilities and the new owner insures the house.

Is a contingent offer realistic on South Hill right now?

More than it was in the spring. In October 2026, ZIPs 98373, 98374 and 98375 had 405 active listings and 123 pending sales, about 3 pending for every 10 active, versus about 5 for every 10 a year earlier. The catch is that your own home may take longer to sell, so plan the contingency period around current days on market.

Trading up on South Hill comes down to choosing which risk you would rather carry: a few weeks of renting back, or a contingency a seller can bump. Neither is wrong. What goes wrong is writing a 45-day contingency into a 64-day market, or agreeing to a rent-back nobody put in writing. Pick the sequence first, check it against the current numbers, then let the forms do their job. More South Hill guides are in the Pierce County guide library.

Let's Plan Your South Hill Move

Call me at (253) 223-2536 or reach out online. I will map out both sides of your move, from listing your current home to the day you get keys to the next one.

Schedule a Consultation